Smart Shopping Guide

How to Spot a Fake Deal

A '70% OFF!' badge proves nothing. Retailers can raise a price in October, 'discount' it in November, and call it a Black Friday miracle. Here's how to check whether a deal is real before you pay.

Advertisement

1. Check the price history, not the strikethrough

The crossed-out 'was' price is chosen by the seller. Free price-history tools show what the item actually sold for over the past months: CamelCamelCamel and Keepa track Amazon prices; a quick search of the product name plus 'price history' finds trackers for other stores. If the 'sale' price is the same as the September price, it isn't a Black Friday deal — it's a Tuesday.

2. Beware the quietly inflated list price

Some products carry a manufacturer's list price that no store has charged in a year. A $200 discount off a price nobody pays is a $0 discount. Compare the sale price across at least two retailers — the honest comparison is price vs price, not price vs 'was'.

3. Match the full model number

Black Friday is full of 'derivative' models: TVs and appliances built for the sale with fewer HDMI ports, dimmer panels or smaller capacities, wearing a model number one letter different from the regular line. Retailers also sell store-specific variants of the same appliance, so a lower price may be a smaller product, not a better deal. Copy the exact model number into a search before you buy.

4. Do the pack-size maths

Two listings with the same product name can contain different quantities — refills, pads, pods, pieces. A lower total for a smaller pack is not a discount. Check price per unit on consumables.

5. Watch the basket, not just the item

6. Use return windows as insurance

Holiday return windows are generous this year — Amazon takes most Nov/Dec purchases back through Jan 31, 2027, and Target's Holiday Price Match Guarantee covers its own price drops on purchases from Nov 1 to Dec 24. Buying from a store with a safety net beats gambling on a no-returns 'doorbuster'.

Our rule on this site: every deal card names the publication or retailer listing we verified the price against, and we never print a 'was' price we couldn't source. If a price can't be verified, the deal doesn't appear.
Advertisement